EnglishفارسیTürkçe

Features

Journal Backtest Prop Firm Scripts Replay & Trade Charts Analysis Playbook Mentor Broker sync

Resources

Pricing Learn Forex calculator Crypto futures calculator Symbols Supported brokers Sign in Get started
Comparison · 2026

The best trading journals in 2026, compared and scored

Nine journals, checked on what decides whether you'll still use one in three months: how your trades get in, what it shows you about them, whether it backtests, whether it fits forex, futures or a prop-firm challenge, what users say about it, and what it really costs.

Who wrote this. TradeAssay makes one of the journals on this list. We kept the comparison fair the only way we know: every price and feature below comes from each company's own website, read on 20 November 2026; every tool, ours included, is scored with the same six rules and every sub-score is published (TradeAssay comes second, behind TradeZella, only because it is new); and each tool is named best at what it is genuinely best at, including the cases where that isn't us. The pictures are each company's own. Prices change; check the vendor's page before you buy.

The short answer

For most traders, TradeAssay is the best all-in-one choice: one plan from $9.99 a month holds the journal, a bar-by-bar backtester on 762 symbols from 1 second to 12 months and a prop-firm challenge simulator, and it syncs MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, Interactive Brokers, Binance, Bybit and Hyperliquid, MetaTrader on its cloud servers 24 hours a day. TradeZella scores highest overall (8.0, against TradeAssay's 7.8) thanks to its long track record, and is the most complete for US stocks and futures. TradesViz has the best free plan for stocks, Edgewonk is best for trading psychology, and TraderSync has the strongest phone apps.

All-in-one: journal, backtester and prop challenge
TradeAssay
US stocks and futures, the most complete
TradeZella
Forex, gold, indices and crypto
TradeAssay
Rehearsing a prop-firm challenge
TradeAssay
Free plan for stock traders
TradesViz
Trading psychology and discipline
Edgewonk
Phone apps
TraderSync
Backtesting first, journal second
FX Replay
A free, verified MT4/MT5 track record
Myfxbook
A simple, no-frills log
Tradervue

The nine side by side

Entry prices are the cheapest paid plan, month to month, with the yearly price where the vendor shows one. "Not stated" means the vendor's pricing page didn't say, not that the feature is missing.

JournalPaid plans fromFree to useMetaTrader 5Backtesting / replayProp-firm tools
TradeZella$35/mo · $315/yrNo free planAuto sync with the investor password, or fileBar by bar on stocks, futures, crypto and CFDsProp Firm Sync
TradeAssay$9.99/mo · $79.99/yrFree plan, no expiryCloud sync on TradeAssay's servers with the investor password, 24 hours a day, or fileBar by bar on 762 symbols, 1 second to 12 months (CME futures and seconds on Elite)Live rule tracking and a challenge simulator
TradesViz$19.99/mo · $14.99/mo yearlyFree plan, stocks onlyAuto importReplay and simulator (Platinum)Compliance checks, challenge mode (Platinum)
TraderSync$29.95/mo7-day trialStatement import; auto sync for some platformsMarket replay simulatorNot stated
Edgewonk$35/mo · $197/yr14-day refundAuto sync while the terminal is openStrategy and performance simulators, no chart replayTracks prop accounts
FX Replay$17.99/mo · $180/yr2 backtest sessionsNot its focusIts core: bar-by-bar replayChallenge mode, per its homepage
TraderWaves$19.99/mo · $239.88/yrFree plan, 3 accountsAuto import (API)Backtesting on ProNot stated
MyfxbookFreeFreeInvestor password, a few updates a dayNoNo
Tradervue$29.95/moFree plan; trials on paid plansImportNoNot stated

How we compared and scored them

A journal is only useful if it is still open on your desk in three months. We scored each one from 1 to 10 on six things that decide that, and the overall score is their plain average:

  1. Getting trades in. Automatic sync beats importing a file, and both beat typing. A 10 syncs most brokers and platforms with nothing to install. We looked at MetaTrader 5 first, because most forex, gold and prop-firm traders use it.
  2. Analysis. Results in R, by setup, session and hour; expectancy; drawdown; and whether you can reopen a trade on its chart.
  3. Backtesting and replay. A 10 replays real history bar by bar, with an order ticket, on many symbols and timeframes.
  4. Prop-firm tools. Whether it knows a firm's daily loss and drawdown rules, shows a breach coming, and can rehearse the challenge.
  5. Price and free plan. What you pay for what you get, including whether there is a free plan and whether backtesting costs a second subscription.
  6. Track record. Years on the market and what users say on Trustpilot. A new tool can't score high here yet.

Fit for your market isn't in the score, because it depends on you: a journal built for US stocks can feel wrong for gold on MT5, and the other way round. That is what the "Best for" line on each tool and which one to choose are for. We make TradeAssay, so we scored it with the same rules and publish every number. Nobody paid to be on this list, and there are no affiliate links on this page.

Our scores

Out of 10, on 20 November 2026, highest overall first.

JournalOverallTrades inAnalysisBacktestingProp firmsPriceTrack record
TradeZella8.0999849
TradeAssay7.8999992
TradesViz7.7897796
TraderSync7.2897559
Edgewonk6.8784679
FX Replay6.7369778
TraderWaves6.3676397
Myfxbook4.86611105
Tradervue4.7771265

TradeZella: the most complete for US stocks and futures

Our score 8.0/10Trustpilot 4.8 · 1,086 reviewsFrom $35/mo

Best for active US stock and futures day traders who will use replay and backtesting every week.

TradeZella is a trading journal and backtesting platform built for US stock and futures day traders, and the journal most lists put first, for good reason. It connects to more than 500 brokers and prop firms, MetaTrader 4 and 5 included (with your investor password, or by uploading a report), and it combines the journal with bar-by-bar backtesting on more than eleven years of data for stocks, futures, crypto and CFDs. Its Pro plan adds trade replay down to one-second charts, and every plan includes AI credits.

TradeZella's dashboard: net P&L, profit factor, trade win rate and average win/loss, a monthly P&L calendar with weekly totals, the Zella score and a cumulative P&L chart.
TradeZella's dashboard, on its demo data. Image: tradezella.com.

Strong at

  • Breadth: 500+ broker and prop-firm integrations
  • Replay and backtesting in one place
  • Polished review tools

Watch out for

  • No free plan
  • Trade replay is not in the entry plan
  • The price climbs fast: $35, $59 and $99 a month

Price: Essential $35/mo ($315/yr), Pro $59/mo ($531/yr), Ultra $99/mo ($891/yr); a Black Friday offer on Pro was running on 20 November 2026. Our side-by-side: TradeZella vs TradeAssay.

TradeAssay: the best all-in-one journal, backtester and prop-firm simulator

Our score 7.8/10Trustpilot: no reviews yetFrom $9.99/mo · free plan

Best for traders who want the journal, a real backtester and prop-firm practice in one subscription, on MetaTrader 4 or 5, cTrader, Interactive Brokers, Binance, Bybit or Hyperliquid.

TradeAssay is an all-in-one trading journal, bar-by-bar backtester and prop-firm challenge simulator for forex, gold, indices, futures and crypto traders. It is ours, so judge this section hardest. It syncs MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, Interactive Brokers, Binance, Bybit and Hyperliquid automatically, and imports reports and spreadsheets from other platforms. MetaTrader is synced on TradeAssay's own cloud servers with your read-only investor password, so your trades are journaled 24 hours a day: nothing to install, and your computer can be off. Every trade is measured in R, by setup, session, weekday and hour, and reopens on its real chart.

The backtester replays real history bar by bar on 762 symbols (forex, metals, indices, commodities, bonds, stocks, 12 CME futures and 431 crypto pairs) on 24 timeframes from 1 second to 12 months, with an order ticket, spreads and costs. Pro opens 750 of the symbols; the CME futures and the seconds charts (188 symbols) are on Elite. A prop-firm simulator runs a firm's whole challenge (daily loss, drawdown, target) on that history before you pay for the real one. It scores 7.8: a 9 on everything we score except track record, where it gets a 2 because it is new and has no Trustpilot reviews yet.

TradeAssay's Overview dashboard on a sample account: net P&L, win rate, profit factor, average trade and average win/loss, the equity curve, drawdown, cumulative and daily net P&L, a month calendar with weekly totals and the recent trades.
TradeAssay's Overview dashboard, on a sample account of 163 trades.

Strong at

  • Cloud sync with the investor password, 24 hours a day
  • Many platforms: MetaTrader, cTrader, IBKR and crypto exchanges
  • Journal and bar-by-bar backtester in one plan
  • Prop-firm rules on every trade, and a challenge simulator
  • The lowest paid price here, and a free plan that doesn't expire

Watch out for

  • Fewer US stock brokers than TradeZella
  • Newer, with a smaller community and no reviews yet
  • One-second charts and CME futures are on Elite
  • On a phone you use it in the browser

Price: Free plan with no expiry (journal, file import, core analysis). Pro $9.99/mo or $79.99/yr; Elite $24.99/mo or $199.99/yr. Every new account gets 7 days of Pro, no card. See the plans.

TradesViz: the most generous free plan for stocks

Our score 7.7/10Trustpilot 3.8 · 72 reviewsFrom $19.99/mo · free plan

Best for stock traders who want serious analytics for free, and data lovers on any market.

TradesViz is an analytics-heavy trading journal: hundreds of charts and reports, custom dashboards, an AI coach on the paid plans, and auto import from many brokers, MetaTrader 5 included. Its free plan is real (up to 3,000 executions a month) but covers stocks only; forex, futures and crypto need Pro. Platinum adds trade replay, a simulator and a prop-challenge mode.

A TradesViz custom dashboard: a cumulative P&L chart, a trades table, a P&L calendar, totals and P&L by tag and by date.
A TradesViz custom dashboard. Image: tradesviz.com.

Strong at

  • A free plan that is usable every day
  • Analytics depth
  • Low paid prices

Watch out for

  • Free covers stocks only
  • So many reports it can feel busy
  • Trustpilot reviewers mention import errors

Price: Basic free; Pro $19.99/mo or $14.99/mo yearly; Platinum $29.99/mo or $22.49/mo yearly (list prices; a 30% sale runs to 30 November 2026).

TraderSync: the strongest phone apps

Our score 7.2/10Trustpilot 4.3 · 328 reviewsFrom $29.95/mo

Best for traders who review on their phone or tablet and want deep statistics.

TraderSync is one of the longest-running trading journals (its app has been on the App Store since 2017) and is best known for its iPhone and iPad apps, last updated in September 2026. It has detailed analytics, a risk overview and an AI assistant called Cypher; it imports statements from many platforms, MetaTrader included, and syncs some platforms automatically. Its market replay simulator lets you trade a past session as if it were live, with finer data on the higher plans.

TraderSync's dashboard in its iPad app: gross P&L, biggest profit, profit factor and win/loss, a long versus short comparison, the account performance curve, daily P&L bars and a risk health overview.
TraderSync's dashboard in its iPad app. Image: TraderSync's App Store listing, September 2026.

Strong at

  • Phone and tablet apps
  • Depth of statistics
  • Market replay simulator

Watch out for

  • Check how your MetaTrader broker connects before paying
  • No free plan, a 7-day trial

Price: Pro $29.95/mo, Premium $49.95/mo, Elite $79.95/mo, with a 7-day trial. (TraderSync's website cannot be read automatically; these are the prices independent reviews agree on.)

Edgewonk: best for trading psychology

Our score 6.8/10Trustpilot 4.7 · 44 reviews$197/yr

Best for traders whose problem is discipline rather than strategy.

Edgewonk is a trading journal built around self-review: rating your discipline and emotions, spotting costly habits, and simulators that show what a different stop or exit would have done. It has been around for years, covers forex, stocks, crypto, futures and options, syncs MetaTrader 4 and 5 automatically while your terminal is open, and tracks any number of prop-firm accounts. There is one plan with every feature.

Edgewonk's home dashboard: net return, win rate, average P&L, profit factor and the EW score, a profit calendar for the month and an evaluation table.
Edgewonk's home dashboard. Image: edgewonk.com.

Strong at

  • Psychology and habit tracking
  • One plan, every feature
  • Good value yearly

Watch out for

  • No chart replay or bar-by-bar backtesting
  • MT sync needs your terminal running

Price: $35/mo or $197/yr, with a 14-day money-back guarantee.

FX Replay: backtesting first

Our score 6.7/10Trustpilot 4.1 · 660 reviewsFrom $17.99/mo · free plan

Best for traders who mainly want to practise and backtest on past charts.

FX Replay is a backtesting platform rather than a journal of your live account: you replay past markets bar by bar, place trades and review the results in its own journal and analytics, and its homepage shows a prop-firm challenge mode. If backtesting is what you need, it does it well; if you also want your live MetaTrader trades journaled, you'll need a second tool, which is the gap a combined journal fills. Our page on FX Replay vs TradeAssay goes into the details.

FX Replay's journal of backtest sessions, with its analytics panel: account balance, expectancy per trade and win rate.
FX Replay's journal and analytics for backtest sessions. Image: fxreplay.com.

Strong at

  • Backtesting is the whole product
  • A free plan to try it

Watch out for

  • Not built to journal your live account
  • The free plan is two sessions
  • Recent Trustpilot reviews mention lag after updates

Price: Beginner free (2 backtest sessions); Intermediate $17.99/mo or $180/yr; Pro $35/mo or $350/yr. (Checked on its pricing page on 7 November 2026; the page refuses automated reading.)

TraderWaves: a free start with a social side

Our score 6.3/10Trustpilot 4.8 · 414 reviewsFrom $19.99/mo · free plan

Best for traders who want a free journal with a leaderboard and trade sharing.

TraderWaves is a newer trading journal with a free plan that lasts (journal, calendar, core metrics, up to three accounts, auto import). Pro adds equity and drawdown analytics, unlimited backtesting, a Monte Carlo simulator and an AI coach. It has iOS and Android apps, and its Trustpilot reviewers praise its clean design.

TraderWaves' dashboard: trade count, win rate, average win and loss, win streak, the WaveScore radar, the balance curve, performance and risk figures and a monthly calendar.
TraderWaves' dashboard. Image: traderwaves.com.

Strong at

  • A free plan with no time limit
  • Sharing and community

Watch out for

  • Its pricing page doesn't say which platforms auto import
  • Prop-firm tools not stated

Price: Free; Pro $19.99/mo or $239.88/yr.

Myfxbook: a free, verified MT4/MT5 track record

Our score 4.8/10Trustpilot 2.4 · 42 reviewsFree

Best for showing a verified track record of an MT4 or MT5 account, for free.

Myfxbook is a free account-statistics site for MetaTrader 4 and 5, and many forex traders use it as a journal. You connect MetaTrader with your investor password and it builds statistics of your account, updated a few times a day, with the option of a public, verified profile; its iPhone app shows the same. You can add notes to trades, but there are no setups, playbooks, R-multiples or backtesting.

Two screens of Myfxbook's iPhone app: a trading system's gain chart with its analytics and trades, and a list of trading systems with their gains.
Myfxbook's iPhone app. Image: Myfxbook's App Store listing.

Strong at

  • Free
  • Verified public track records

Watch out for

  • Statistics of an account, not a review of your decisions
  • Updates are not real time

Price: Free.

Tradervue: a simple, no-frills log

Our score 4.7/10Trustpilot 2.2 · 11 reviewsFrom $29.95/mo · free plan

Best for equity traders who want a clean log and charts of their trades, nothing more.

Tradervue is one of the original online trading journals: a clean trade log for equity traders. It imports from many brokers and platforms (MetaTrader 5 among them), draws intraday charts of each trade and handles stocks, futures, forex and options. It has a free plan, and its paid plans come with a trial. It doesn't try to be a backtester.

Tradervue's trades page: profit factor, winning versus losing trades, average win versus loss and P&L above a filtered table of trades with tags and notes.
Tradervue's trades page. Image: tradervue.com.

Strong at

  • Simplicity
  • Clear charts of each trade

Watch out for

  • No backtesting or replay
  • Few prop-firm tools
  • Most of its few Trustpilot reviews are about billing

Price: Free plan; Silver $29.95/mo, Gold $49.95/mo, with a trial on both.

What Trustpilot reviewers say

Read on each company's Trustpilot page on 20 November 2026, highest score first. A score built on a few dozen reviews moves quickly, so read it next to the number of reviews.

JournalTrustScoreReviewsPraised forComplaints
TradeZella4.81,086Fast, helpful support; easy journaling and backtestingSome sync and setup trouble, slow live chat at times
TraderWaves4.8414Clean design, automatic sync, free analyticsOccasional connection issues; users want more integrations
Edgewonk4.744Time-saving import, responsive team, valueFew; one older review on the yearly-only plan
TraderSync4.3328Deep journaling and customisation, responsive supportBugs after a redesign, sync and calculation errors
FX Replay4.1660Backtesting, responsive supportLag and freezes after updates, chart changes
TradesViz3.872Detailed analytics, a responsive founderImport errors, billing and cancelling
Myfxbook2.442Detailed analyticsSlow support, refunds, accounts not matching
Tradervue2.211Few recent reviewsCharges after cancelling, slow support
TradeAssayNone yet0Its Trustpilot page opened in November 2026. If you use TradeAssay, a review, good or bad, helps the next trader decide.

Which one should you choose?

If you…Choose
trade forex or gold on MetaTrader 5TradeAssay, or Edgewonk if psychology is your focus
are working through a prop-firm challengeTradeAssay to rehearse it on history; TradeZella or TradesViz Platinum to track it
day-trade US stocks or futuresTradeZella, or TraderSync if you review on your phone
want to pay nothingTradesViz (stocks), TradeAssay's free plan (MT5 and forex), Myfxbook (track record)
mostly want to backtestFX Replay, or TradeAssay to keep backtests and live trades together
take a few trades a weekA spreadsheet is enough: our free Excel template

If you trade on MetaTrader 5, read this first

Most of the well-known journals were built for US stocks first, and their MetaTrader support was added later. Before you pay, check three things:

  • How it connects. Some journals read your account from their servers with the investor password (TradeAssay, TradeZella, Myfxbook); others need your terminal running (Edgewonk, or any journal that runs a plug-in inside MetaTrader), or a report you export and upload by hand.
  • Your broker's symbols. XAUUSDm, EURUSD.pro or US30.cash should land as gold, EURUSD and the Dow, with the right dollar value per lot.
  • Your broker's clock. MT5 shows server time, usually two or three hours ahead of UTC. A journal that ignores it puts your London-session trades in the wrong session.

More on this: a trading journal for MetaTrader and a journal for prop-firm accounts.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best trading journal in 2026?

For most traders, TradeAssay (7.8 out of 10) is the best all-in-one choice: the journal, a bar-by-bar backtester on 762 symbols and a prop-firm challenge simulator in one plan from $9.99 a month, syncing MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, Interactive Brokers, Binance, Bybit and Hyperliquid, MetaTrader on its cloud servers 24 hours a day. TradeZella (8.0) scores highest overall thanks to its long track record and is the most complete for US stocks and futures. TradesViz (7.7) has the best free plan for stocks, Edgewonk is best for trading psychology, and TraderSync has the strongest phone apps.

What is the best free trading journal?

TradesViz has the most generous free plan for stock traders (3,000 executions a month). For MetaTrader traders, TradeAssay's free plan never expires and includes the journal, file import, core analysis and two backtest sessions, and Myfxbook is free for verified MT4 and MT5 track records.

Which trading journal works best with MetaTrader 5?

TradeAssay, TradeZella, TradesViz and Edgewonk all sync MetaTrader 5. TradeAssay keeps the connection on its own servers with your read-only investor password, so nothing runs on your computer; Edgewonk syncs while your terminal is open.

Which trading journal syncs MetaTrader 5 without installing anything?

TradeAssay and TradeZella read your MT5 account from their own servers with your read-only investor password, so nothing runs on your computer and it can be switched off; Myfxbook does the same for account statistics. Edgewonk, and any journal that runs a plug-in inside MetaTrader, needs your terminal open.

How many symbols can you backtest on TradeAssay?

762 symbols of real history: forex, metals, indices, commodities, bonds, stocks, 12 CME futures and 431 crypto pairs, on 24 timeframes from 1 second to 12 months. Pro opens 750 of them; the CME futures and the seconds charts (188 symbols) are on Elite, and backtesting comes with Pro and the 7-day trial. See every symbol.

Which trading journal is best for prop firm traders?

TradeAssay, if you want to rehearse a firm's challenge on historical data before paying for it and see its daily loss and drawdown rules on every trade; it carries the rules of FTMO, FundedNext, The5ers, Topstep, FundingPips and other firms. TradeZella's Prop Firm Sync connects many firms' accounts, and TradesViz Platinum adds compliance checks.

What is the best trading journal for gold (XAUUSD)?

Gold is mostly traded on MetaTrader 5 as XAUUSD, often under a broker's own name such as XAUUSDm or GOLD. A journal for gold should read that name as gold with the right dollar value per lot and use your broker's clock. TradeAssay does both, and backtests gold on one-minute history since 2003.

Is TradeZella worth it?

For an active US stock or futures day trader who will use its replay, backtesting and 500+ broker integrations, yes. It starts at $35 a month ($315 a year) and has no free plan, so a forex or MT5 trader on a budget gets most of the same from TradeAssay at $9.99 a month.

What is a cheaper alternative to TradeZella?

TradeAssay (from $9.99 a month or $79.99 a year, with a free plan and bar-by-bar backtesting), TradesViz (free plan, paid from $19.99 a month) and TraderWaves (free plan, Pro $19.99 a month).

Which trading journals have the best Trustpilot ratings?

On 20 November 2026: TradeZella 4.8 (1,086 reviews), TraderWaves 4.8 (414), Edgewonk 4.7 (44), TraderSync 4.3 (328), FX Replay 4.1 (660), TradesViz 3.8 (72), Myfxbook 2.4 (42) and Tradervue 2.2 (11). TradeAssay had no reviews yet.

Do I need a trading journal for a prop firm challenge?

Most failed challenges break the daily loss or drawdown rule rather than miss the target. A journal that knows your firm's rules shows how close each trade took you to them; TradeAssay can also run the whole challenge on historical data before you pay for it. See why traders fail prop firm challenges.

Can I just use Excel?

Yes, if you take a few trades a week. A spreadsheet stops being enough when typing every trade costs you the review, or when you want each trade on its chart. Our free Excel template goes into TradeAssay's Import whole when you move.

Written by the TradeAssay Team, traders with more than seven years of experience in forex, gold, indices and futures. Prices and features were read on each company's own website, and Trustpilot ratings on Trustpilot, on 20 November 2026. The pictures are each company's own, from its website or its App Store listing. If something here is out of date, write to support@tradeassay.com and we'll correct it.

Trade on MetaTrader 5? Connect your account once and every trade is journaled, measured in R and on its chart.

Start free

Trading foreign exchange, futures and other leveraged products carries a high level of risk and is not suitable for every investor. Product names, logos and screenshots belong to their owners and are shown only to compare. This page is not investment advice.

Your next trade deserves a reason.

Bring in your history and see what it says — free, in a few minutes.

Create your free account
Help centre

Answers to what traders ask us most — and a ticket to a person when they aren't enough.

Open help
Write to us

support@tradeassay.com — read by the people who build the app.

Send an email
Learn

Long reads on sample size, R and prop-firm rules, each with a calculator.

Start reading